When Can I Change my Medicare Supplement Plan?

Medicare – like most large, complicated systems – can be confusing. There are any number of issues with Medicare that can be hard to decipher. One of the most confusing involves when you can and cannot sign up for or change a Medicare Supplement plan, also known as Medigap.

The rules for enrolling in and changing Medicare Supplement Insurance plans are different than the rules for other parts of Medicare. Let us help you understand the differences.

Can I Change My Medicare Supplement Plan At Any Time?

You can apply for a new Medicare Supplement plan at any time, however, medical underwriting may apply and you may be denied coverage due to health conditions.

Below are additional circumstances and scenarios to consider:

What Is a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plan?

Original Medicare, which includes Part A and Part B, covers most but not all of your medical care. Some costs that aren’t covered, such as Medicare deductibles, copays, coinsurance and some other costs. Medigap plans are designed to fill those gaps by supplementing your Original Medicare coverage to pay for certain out-of-pocket costs. 

A Medicare Supplement plan may pay your coinsurance or copayments from Medicare Part A and Part B. Some Medigap plans also cover Part A and/or Part B deductibles and other costs.

You can use the chart below to compare the out-of-pocket Medicare costs that different types of Medigap plans cover.

Original Medicare is offered by the government. Part A is usually free for most beneficiaries, and Part B carries a monthly premium. Medigap plans, however, are sold by private insurance companies. You must shop for these plans, and a licensed insurance agent can help you pick the one that offers you the best coverage at the best rates.

Medicare Supplement plans carry letters to designate the benefits each type of plan offers. Thus, every plan with the same lettered name has the same basic coverage almost anywhere in the country.

For example, Medicare Supplement Plan G sold by X Insurance Company will include the same benefits as a Supplement Plan G sold by Y Insurance Company in most states. The exceptions are Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin, which standardize their supplement plans differently.

When Can You Enroll in a Medigap Plan?

If you do consider enrolling in a Medigap plan Medigap plans, you should try to apply for a plan during your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period. Your Medigap Open Enrollment Period is a 6-month period that starts the day you are both 65 years old and enrolled in Medicare Part B.

During your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period, you do not have to undergo medical underwriting, which means the insurance company cannot turn you down or charge you higher premiums because of any pre-existing health condition. 

If you don't change Medicare Supplement insurance plans during your Medigap Open Enrollment Period, your insurer can force you to undergo medical underwriting, and they can now assess your health history during the application process and can turn you down if it chooses. 

Can I Change From a Medicare Advantage Plan to a Medigap Plan Without Underwriting?

You can switch from a Medicare Advantage plan to a Medigap (Medicare Supplement) plan without underwriting only in specific situations:

• Within 12 months of joining a Medicare Advantage plan for the first time (trial right).

• If you’re in your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period (starts when you’re 65+ and first enroll in Medicare Part B).

• If you qualify for a Guaranteed Issue Right (e.g., your MA plan ends, you move out of the service area, or the plan breaks Medicare rules).

Outside these scenarios, most states allow insurers to require medical underwriting, meaning they can deny coverage or charge more based on your health.

When Can You Change Medigap Plans?

Just as you can enroll at any time of the year (as long as you have Part B), you also can change Medicare Supplement plans at any time. But again, if it’s not during your Medigap Open Enrollment Period or if you don’t have a guaranteed issue right, you must pass the provider’s medical underwriting process to qualify in most states.

Some states – including California, Washington, Oregon, Missouri and some others – allow you to change Medicare Supplement plans without going through the underwriting process.

Can You Change Medicare Supplement Plans With Pre-Existing Conditions?

Most of the time, yes but it depends on your situation. If you have had your Medicare Supplement policy for less than 6 months, you may need to wait for a different policy that is willing to accept your pre-existing conditions. Medigap providers can deny coverage for pre-existing conditions under federal law for the first 6 months. 

What States Allow You to Change Medicare Supplement Plans Without Underwriting?

Guaranteed issue protections for switching to Medigap or altering Medigap plans are offered by 12 states on an annual basis. These states include California, Connecticut, Idaho, Illinois, Maine, Massachusetts, Missouri, Nevada, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, and Washington.

What Are Guaranteed-Issue Rights?

The main way to avoid medical underwriting is if you have a Medicare Supplement insurance guaranteed-issue right.

Some guaranteed-issue rights occur when:

• Your Medigap insurance company went bankrupt or ended your policy through no fault of your own.
• Your Medigap insurance company committed fraud and you are canceling your policy.
• You leave your current Medigap insurer because the company misled you.
• You signed up for a Medicare Advantage plan for the first time, but then choose to cancel that policy and return to Original Medicare with a Medicare Supplement insurance plan instead.
• You have a Medicare SELECT plan, and you move out of the service area. Medicare SELECT plans have restricted provider networks that you can choose from. If you leave the network area, you can switch to a standardized Medicare Supplement insurance plan with the same or fewer basic benefits as your SELECT plan, or you can purchase certain other Medicare Supplement plans.
• You’ve been enrolled in a Medicare Supplement insurance plan for fewer than six months. Your insurance company may agree to sell you a new policy with the same basic benefits, but you may have to wait up to six months before the new plan covers any pre-existing health conditions. 

If any of the above situations apply to you, you can switch Medigap plans without medical underwriting. You must apply no later than 63 calendars days after the previous health coverage ends.

Please note that there are other situations when you may qualify for a guaranteed-issue right. Find out if you qualify for a guaranteed-issue right today. 

If your Medigap Open Enrollment Period is over and you don't qualify for a guaranteed-issue right, you can still make changes, but it could cost you.

The Medicare Supplement “Free Look” Period

When you switch Medicare Supplement Insurance plans, you generally are allowed 30 days to decide to keep it or not. This 30-day “free look” period starts when your new Medicare Supplement plan takes effect. To qualify, you need to pay the premiums for both your new plan and your old plan for one month.

Should You Change Medigap Plans?

You may want to consider changing your plan or insurance company to increase your benefits or lower your monthly costs.

If you are happy with your current policy, there is no reason to change plans. But you may be interested in changing policies under certain circumstances: 

• Better price
  Every September, insurance companies must send out a Medicare Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) letter to Medicare beneficiaries. This letter tells you of any changes to your rates. If your rates go up, you may want to consider looking for a new policy. You can shop around for a similar plan offered by the same company or a different company for a lower premium.
  
  
• More coverage
  If you decide you need more coverage, you can switch to a different plan letter to get more benefits.
  
  
• Less Coverage
  Likewise, if you don’t need or want to keep paying for benefits you don’t use, you might consider switching to a more basic plan if it offers a lower premium.
  
  
• Different Provider
  If you are unhappy with your insurance company for any reason, you can purchase a plan from a different insurance underwriter.

Call to speak with a licensed insurance agent who can help you compare Medicare Supplement plans in your area. They can help you change plans once you find the best plan for your needs. You can also compare plans online for free.

Can I Switch from Plan N to Plan G?

Transitioning from Plan N to Plan G is permissible at any point throughout the year. However, if you find yourself beyond the 6-month Open Enrollment period, you might need to respond to health-related inquiries in order to proceed with the switch.