Home > Costs > Medicare Supplement Insurance Costs

Medicare Supplement Insurance Costs

Christian Worstell by Christian Worstell    |    Published Oct 03, 2019    |    Reviewed by John Krahnert

There are several variables that may affect the cost of a Medicare Supplement Insurance plan. Below, we examine some of the most common pricing factors to help you find a quality Medigap policy at a fair price.

Family of all ages smiling

4 Things That Can Affect the Price of Your Medigap Policy

1. Medical underwriting

If you enroll in a Medigap plan outside of your open enrollment period, you may be subject to medical underwriting by the insurance company. This means that the cost of your Medicare Supplement Insurance plan may be based on your current health status and medical history.

Underwriting is not permitted for Medicare beneficiaries who sign up during the open enrollment period or those who have a guaranteed issue right. Your six-month Medigap open enrollment period begins as soon as you are at least age 65 and are receiving Medicare Part B benefits. There are some exceptions for people younger than 65 who have qualifying conditions or disabilities.

2. Discounts

Insurance companies that sell Medicare Supplement Insurance plans may offer discounts for non-smokers, women, married couples, patients who pay their premiums electronically and more. Any potential discounts are not standardized and will vary based on the insurance provider.

3. Location

Medigap plans sold in one particular market may be quite different from the same plans sold in another part of the country. For example, Medigap Plan F could be found in San Jose in 2016 for between $135 and $168 per month. But in New York City, the cost of the same Medicare Supplement Insurance plan offering the same basic benefits could range from $218 to $444. 

4. Plan type

There are 10 standardized Medigap plan types available in most states (Minnesota, Massachusetts and Wisconsin have different plan options), and each type of plan offers a slightly different combination of basic benefits in nine designated coverage areas. Because the amount of coverage differs from one plan to the next, so too will the cost.

Use the chart below to compare the basic benefits of each type of Medicare Supplement Insurance plan.

2019 Medigap plans comparison chart

Medicare Supplement Insurance Plan Cost Structures

Another variable that may affect the cost of a Medicare Supplement Insurance plan is your age. There are three main ways in which age may be factored into the cost of a Medigap plan.

  • Community-rated
    Under community-rated Medigap plan pricing, each Medicare beneficiary is charged the same rate, regardless of their age. The cost of the plan will not increase over time as a result of the increasing age of the insured, but costs could increase as a result of inflation.

  • Issue-age-rated
    This type of Medicare Supplement Insurance plan cost structure is based on your age at the time of application. Typically, the younger you are when you purchase the Medigap plan, the less you will have to pay for the plan. Again, these plan costs will not increase due to your age but may increase due to inflation.
  • Attained-age-rated
    Attained-age rated Medigap plan costs are similar to that of an issue-age-rated plan, but the cost will increase as you age. Younger enrollees can generally expect to pay less for the plan initially but will see the costs increase over time due to their age.  

Speak with a licensed agent at 1-800-995-4219 to compare your Medicare Supplement Insurance options.

Resource Center

Comparing Medicare Supplement Insurance Plans and Costs

While Medicare Supplement Insurance plans have standardized basic benefits, their costs will vary. There are three primary types of Medigap pricing structures.

Read More

Factors That Affect the Cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance

Understanding all the factors that affect the cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance can help you better gauge how much you might expect to pay.

Read More

Medicare Supplement Insurance Comparison Guide

Medicare Supplement Insurance can help cover some of the health care costs that come with Original Medicare. Compare plan benefits today.

Read More

What Affects Medicare Supplement Insurance Rates?

Learn more about how Medicare Supplement Insurance plan rates are determined and get free policy quotes from a licensed insurance agent.

Read More

Medicare Supplement Insurance Plan C: An Overview

Learn about Medicare Supplement Insurance Plan C benefits, and how they compare to other Medigap plans.

Read More

Choosing the Best Medicare Supplement Insurance Plan

Is Medicare costing you a fortune? A Medicare Supplement Insurance plan will reduce Medicare out-of-pocket costs. Enroll today!

Read More

Reduce Your Medicare Out-of-Pocket Costs With a Medigap Plan

If you don't have a Medicare Supplement Insurance plan, you may be paying too much for your Medicare benefits. Here's how to curb the costs.

Read More

Medicare Supplement Insurance Plans and Health Care Costs

A Medigap plan is a health insurance plan that can help pay for some out-of-pocket Medicare costs. Find a Medigap plan that meets your needs.

Read More

Medicare Supplement Insurance Plan Comparison Guide

Medicare Supplement Insurance plans help cover some out-of-pocket costs that Original Medicare leaves. Compare the basic benefits of each type of plan.

Read More

Every 13 minutes, we help someone enroll in a plan.

Sign up for more information!

Enter your email address and get a free guide to Medicare and Medicare Supplement Insurance.

Sign Up Now